call-iconClick to Call
The Vaughan Agency

505 Mulberry Heights Road
Pomeroy, OH 45769

map-iconGet Directions

Who We Are

Meet Our Staff

Donald E. Vaughan, Sr.

Donald E. Vaughan, Sr.

Donald E. Vaughan, Sr. is currently the Owner of The Vaughan Agency, LLC. His career has spanned a half a century with experience in retail, wholesale and finally insurance. Donald began the business as a “start up” and for the first few years, was the only employee, Today, the Agency has six employees and is still continuing to grow.

Donald considers himself first to be an entrepreneur and a problem solver. His background in insurance and financial products encompass almost two decades. His experience helping clients with their individual health insurance plans, Medicare plans and life insurance make him the “Go To” person in our area. He also enjoys the challenges of helping groups with their employee benefits and solving the complex problems facing our employers today. Helping everyone understand the Affordable Care Act (aka Obama Care) and how to properly utilize their benefits has been a critical task most recently.

Beside his insurance business, Donald is involved with many non-profits in the community (like Rotary), serving on several boards, volunteering, leading mission teams, etc. Some of his past experience includes two decades as a Scout Master, almost three decades as a Sunday School Teacher and a decade on the Meigs County Chamber Board.

Donald is married to Pamela (Nicinsky) Vaughan, is the father of three children and the grandfather to seven grandchildren.

You can contact Donald directly at 740-992-9784 (Office), text him at 740-591-2317 or email him at

Ashlee Enslen

Ashlee Enslen

Ashlee Enslen was born and raised in Ohio and has called Meigs County home most of her life. She graduated from Meigs High School in 2000 and from there she went on to Hocking College.

Ashlee started her insurance career at The Vaughan Agency in the spring of 2002. She first dealt with the health and life insurance side of the agency, helping

clients with medical claims, billing issues, and assisting with group health insurance. From there she began to work with the personal lines side of the agency, where she dealt mainly in customer service. She continues to work in personal lines, specializing in homeowner's insurance.

Ashlee is married to Clay Enslen and they have 3 daughters: Eva, Mya, and Ana.

In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her husband and daughters, shopping with her friends, and she enjoys traveling.

Ashlee's email address is

Erin Cross

Erin Cross

Erin Cross is currently working in the Life and Health area of The Vaughan Agency, LLC.

Erin lives in Middleport, OH and has lived there her entire life. She graduated from Meigs High School in 2002 and Rio Grande Community College in 2005 with an Associate's Degree in Business Management.

Erin joined The Vaughan Agency, LLC in the Fall of 2014. She enjoys helping her local community in which she has grown up in.

Outside of insurance, Erin enjoys spending time with her husband, Austin and keeps busy managing a Hair Salon and multiple rental properties.

Erin's email address is

Kara Glaze

Kara Glaze

Kara Glaze is currently a Commercial Insurance agent at the Vaughan Agency, LLC in Pomeroy, Ohio.

She resides in Pomeroy, Ohio and is married to Zach Glaze and mother to Layla and Jackson. Kara graduated from Meigs High School in 2002 with classes focused on accounting and business. She completed an internship in 2004 where she lived in Orlando, Florida and completed the college program at Walt Disney World where she specialized in customer service. She earned an Associate's Degree in Business Management from the University of Rio Grande in 2005,

Kara has almost 10 years in insurance experience. She has taken the skills from her experience and education to provide the best customer service to her clients. Kara prides herself in giving her all every day and making sure every customer is pleased with the outcome.

Besides her career in insurance, Kara has donated countless hours to Meigs Primary as a Volunteer and PTO President.

Amber Hopkins

Amber Hopkins

Amber Hopkins is a Licensed Insurance Agent in Ohio and West Virginia. She joined The Vaughan Agency several years ago and is currently focusing on auto and homeowner's coverage.

Amber loves to work with people and enjoys communicating with and helping clients find the best plans for the best price. You'!l be hard pressed to find another Insurance Agent any friendlier than Amber.

Besides being one of the top performing agents at The Vaughan Agency, Amber enjoys cooking for the free community dinners and for her friends and family. She is actively involved in her church and various other community activities,

Amber is a lifelong resident here in Southern Ohio and is married to Brad. They have two beautiful daughters Taylor and Baylie with which she participates as a Room Mom, Cheerleader and Basketball Coach.


The Vaughan Agency was established by Donald Vaughan in 2000, he started the agency from the ground up. In the beginning Don focused on Health Insurance and Employee Benefits. Two years later his daughter, Ashlee joined him helping clients deal with claims and focusing on helping clients understand their benefit. A year later, his son, Donald Edward Vaughan Jr. (Dodger), joined the team. Dodger started the property and casualty side of our agency, handling homeowners and auto insurance.

Today, our agency employs 6 people, each specializing in different lines of insurance.

We know you rely on us to protect your most valuable assets, including family, home, cars, and finances. That's why our #1 priority is to protect our clients, period!


At The Vaughan Agency we don't just say we care about our community, we demonstrate it. From helping serve community dinners, to being involved in civic organizations like Rotary and the Chamber of Commerce, to serving in local churches our insurance advisors are deeply committed to our community. We bring that same level of commitment to our clients every day.

Some of the ways we have in the past include: Blessings in a Backpack and Project Clothe the Kids.


When you send your friends and family to The Vaughan Agency for all their insurance needs, we will donate $5 to the local charity of your choice and we send you a $5 gift card to a local restaurant!


Also, consider going to Facebook to review us! Liking our page, leaving a review of much we saved you, or how we helped you.

You are also welcome to share how you were treated by our agents.

Great reviews aren't why we do what we do, but it helps to know you notice.

Why Work With Us?

  • Locally owned and operated
  • Works with multiple carriers
  • Combines policies for best rates
  • Customer friendly services
  • Print out your auto ID cards from home, anytime!

Servicing these States

  • Ohio
  • West Virginia